Chapter 3 · Every sector
The whole U.S. economy, sector by sector.
Twenty NAICS sectors with payroll jobs, real hourly pay, real output and two adoption measures. This is the Main Street context any AI claim has to fit inside. None of these series, by itself, isolates an AI effect.
Small multiples
Payroll jobs, January 2019 = 100.
Same scale logic in every panel (each indexed to its own January 2019 level). The dotted line is 100. Agriculture is absent because the BLS payroll survey excludes farms.
Where growth came from
Contributions to real GDP growth by industry, 2025.
Percentage points of the 2.3% growth in U.S. real GDP in 2025, by industry. These are accounting contributions, not AI attributions.
Contributions to percent change in real GDP, 2025
Bars by industry. Largest contributor: Real estate and leasing at 0.54 points.
Caveat. Negative contributions are possible. A sector's contribution reflects its size and its real growth. It says nothing about the cause of that growth.
Inspect the evidence
- How much of any sector's growth is due to AI.
- Quarterly volatility within the year.
- ValueAdded.xlsx, sheet TVA102-A
- Sector rows matched by exact BEA line title
- No rescaling
Text description. Bars by industry. Largest contributor: Real estate and leasing at 0.54 points.