Sector · NAICS 44
Retail trade
Inventory, waste, customer service, sales, scheduling, worker hours, pay, business survival.
Payroll jobs
2026-10 (prelim.), −0.7% vs Jan 2019
Real hourly pay
Jan 2019 dollars, +2.8% vs Jan 2019
Real output
Value added, 2019Q4 to 2026Q2
Value added
2025, current dollars
- What is being adopted?
- 49.9% of Ramp retail customers (Oct 2026); 19.1% of retailers in Census (late Oct 2026).
- What changed economically?
- Context series only.
- What happened to workers?
- Sales tasks are 11.6% of U.S. Claude.ai conversations (task labels).
- What did consumers or patients gain?
- Not assembled.
- What remains unproven?
- Margin, waste and scheduling effects.
- Major workflows
- Product content, customer service, forecasting.
- Barriers
- Thin margins, staff turnover.
- Outcome studies
- Ramp/Revelio consumer and administrative group: -1.2% (SE 4.1), not significant.
Context, not attribution
Jobs, pay and output.
Payroll employment
Payroll jobs in Retail trade, −0.7% since January 2019.
Caveat. Employment moves with demand, rates, migration and the pandemic recovery. The ChatGPT marker shows timing only.
Inspect the evidence
- Hours, hires or separations.
- Self-employed and farm workers.
- BLS series CES4200000001
- Monthly values as published; last two months preliminary
Text description. Payroll jobs in Retail trade, −0.7% since January 2019.
Average hourly earnings, real
Real average hourly earnings, +2.8% since January 2019.
Caveat. Averages shift when the mix of workers changes (e.g., low-wage layoffs in 2020 raised the average).
Inspect the evidence
- Benefits, hours or job quality.
- Distribution within the sector.
- BLS CES4200000003 divided by CPI-U (CUSR0000SA0) relative to Jan 2019
Text description. Real average hourly earnings, +2.8% since January 2019.
Real value added
Real value added index for Retail trade, +6.7% since 2019Q4.
Caveat. Real output by industry is revised annually. Growth here cannot be attributed to AI without further evidence.
Inspect the evidence
- BEA ValueAdded.xlsx sheet TVA103-Q
- Matched by exact BEA line title
Text description. Real value added index for Retail trade, +6.7% since 2019Q4.
Businesses on Ramp paying for AI
Ramp adoption in Retail trade reached 49.9%.
Caveat. Vendor sample. Census (representative) puts this sector at 19.1% using AI in late Oct 2026, a different question and universe.
Inspect the evidence
Text description. Ramp adoption in Retail trade reached 49.9%.